Lets go more in depth with this pants on head retarded culinary analogy.
There is Chef that you heard always serves out horrible dishes. You know that the only people giving him positive yelp reviews are either members of his own staff, or people that have shit for a palate.
This Chef comes out with a new dish, lets call it a risotto (you watch Ramsay).
You exclaim how it is horrible because you think he is a horrible Chef.
I tried it before I said why I didn't like it.