For me, interviewing that juror that left b/c of medical emergency (meth addict? idk) and the interviews in the bar, totally kill the documentary for me.
The case smells to me like trying to take partial evidence and match it against the probable suspect.
The bit that struck me was the mismatch to the guys that said they spotted Avery or w/e on Halloween, that whole bit about passing each other on Avery Road. That seemed super suspect and like, why would they be lying about that.